- RTI’s are growing, however this growth is in line with the spread of other diseases in developing nations. Passengers, pedestrians, and cyclists are the most in danger. This sounds more like a growing metropolitan issue.
- The World Bank and WHO predict that there will be an increase in RTI’s over the next twenty years.
- A considerable amount of these deaths are due to poor road condition and other infrastructure issues. In the CIS there are about three times as many RTI’s than the EU.
- Kazakhstan and the Russian Federation lead the RTI death rates in Who-Euro member nations in 2007 statistics. In later data, most of these deaths look like pedestrian and four-wheeled vehicles. Also, children and young adults die more frequently.
The report goes into some economic calculations on these deaths and tries to factor in other cost factors.
** Honestly I’m not finding this report that shocking. Children and young adults die more because they are not as hardy physically and some young adults may be behind the wheel themselves. Maybe I’m biased because I’ve lived in both types of US cities, one being very car oriented (Los Angeles, CA) and one being very pedestrian/light rail oriented (Portland, OR). I’ve almost been hit by cars walking and driving countless times due to various issues some infrastructure, some driver training, some my fault. I’ll contain the rest of my opinion until I finish the whole report.
report link
Showing posts with label roads. Show all posts
Showing posts with label roads. Show all posts
Tuesday, December 01, 2009
Confronting “Death on Wheels”: Making Roads Safe in Europe and Central Asia // Chapter 2: The Epidemic of Road Traffic Injuries
Labels:
pedestrians,
road safety,
roads,
transportation infrastructure
Monday, November 30, 2009
Confronting “Death on Wheels”: Making Roads Safe in Europe and Central Asia
This World Bank report is focused on how to improve road safety in the CIS and other developing regions. It is essentially a reminder for a 2004 report by a similar title that came to the conclusion that more funding was needed to improve infrastructure and vehicle and operator regulations. The following posts on this will be the usual chapter breakdowns that have been done for prior reports:
Chapter 1: Introduction
- Transportation sector is highly impacted by spending and decisions of most of the other sectors, especially in terms of planning and zoning.
- Road and noise pollution are serious environmental impacts and contribute to the high external cost of car transportation.
- Road Traffic Injuries (RTI)’s are defined in the report as any death occurring due to a traffic incident within 30 days. There is an increasing risk for RTI’s in developing nations due to a lack of regulation and continual funding infrastructure capacity/maintenance.
- Road safety should be an integral piece in transportation policy, which also includes pedestrian alternatives to car transportation.
- “The Commission for Global Road Safety (200) also notes that while the primary rationale for investing more than US$4 billion each year in road infrastructure is to improve road transport efficiency to spur economic growth, the risk and magnitude of increased societal costs associated with rising RTIs is often overlooked”
- This report was primarily written for an internal audience and to raise awareness of how other sectors can influence transportation.
report link
Chapter 1: Introduction
- Transportation sector is highly impacted by spending and decisions of most of the other sectors, especially in terms of planning and zoning.
- Road and noise pollution are serious environmental impacts and contribute to the high external cost of car transportation.
- Road Traffic Injuries (RTI)’s are defined in the report as any death occurring due to a traffic incident within 30 days. There is an increasing risk for RTI’s in developing nations due to a lack of regulation and continual funding infrastructure capacity/maintenance.
- Road safety should be an integral piece in transportation policy, which also includes pedestrian alternatives to car transportation.
- “The Commission for Global Road Safety (200) also notes that while the primary rationale for investing more than US$4 billion each year in road infrastructure is to improve road transport efficiency to spur economic growth, the risk and magnitude of increased societal costs associated with rising RTIs is often overlooked”
- This report was primarily written for an internal audience and to raise awareness of how other sectors can influence transportation.
report link
Wednesday, November 11, 2009
NEWS: Op-Ed from NYT Pushes for Alternative Road Uses
One of the Op-Ed's out of the New York Times this morning, Revolutionary Road is basically advocating for making the roads serve a different use. I actually have a couple of huge issues with her suggestions.
"The most obvious use for the Interstate’s corridors is rail transportation. If we are going to spend billions rehabbing the highways, shouldn’t we, at the same time, invest in adjacent rail lines like the 800-mile high-speed rail system voters approved last year in California"
> The author clearly doesn't realize that building adjacent rail is expensive due to having to procure right of way. Living in LA, a lot of residential properties back up to the freeway, so essentially you're going to be dislocating families to build? The other option is building the rail into the existing right of way. Also problematic for transit-planning reasons. Some have suggested to build a lightrail in between the north-south/east-west bound lanes in the center. Maybe plausible, but excess right of way is still going to be needed for the pedestrian connections necessary for getting over the freeway. Probably through someone's backyard.
"The corridors are also perfectly suited for the transportation of energy. Power generated from rural wind farms and solar plants could run through lines buried under the highways to big cities where electricity is needed. The plug-in hybrid vehicles that will someday use the highways could charge up from this grid. And when left idling, these cars would also be able to supply power back to the grid at times of peak demand, while their owners work or shop by the roadside. "
> Wait. What? I can't tell if Jacobs wants to repave the freeways with a magical solar surface that would allow for the cards to supply power back to the grid and self-charge or if she wants to burry the lines and repave the freeway. Putting utilities under roads is not a new idea and is currently how water/sewer/gas lines are hooked up. Exisiting use. Try again.
The realities of infrastructure developement are challenging and complex. They do encourage sprawl (growth) but ultimately it is up to zoning codes and cities to control how much sprawl they have. A freeway will encourage development outside a major city, but it does not dictate whether there will be single family homes or mixed use projects.
What a disappointing article.
"The most obvious use for the Interstate’s corridors is rail transportation. If we are going to spend billions rehabbing the highways, shouldn’t we, at the same time, invest in adjacent rail lines like the 800-mile high-speed rail system voters approved last year in California"
> The author clearly doesn't realize that building adjacent rail is expensive due to having to procure right of way. Living in LA, a lot of residential properties back up to the freeway, so essentially you're going to be dislocating families to build? The other option is building the rail into the existing right of way. Also problematic for transit-planning reasons. Some have suggested to build a lightrail in between the north-south/east-west bound lanes in the center. Maybe plausible, but excess right of way is still going to be needed for the pedestrian connections necessary for getting over the freeway. Probably through someone's backyard.
"The corridors are also perfectly suited for the transportation of energy. Power generated from rural wind farms and solar plants could run through lines buried under the highways to big cities where electricity is needed. The plug-in hybrid vehicles that will someday use the highways could charge up from this grid. And when left idling, these cars would also be able to supply power back to the grid at times of peak demand, while their owners work or shop by the roadside. "
> Wait. What? I can't tell if Jacobs wants to repave the freeways with a magical solar surface that would allow for the cards to supply power back to the grid and self-charge or if she wants to burry the lines and repave the freeway. Putting utilities under roads is not a new idea and is currently how water/sewer/gas lines are hooked up. Exisiting use. Try again.
The realities of infrastructure developement are challenging and complex. They do encourage sprawl (growth) but ultimately it is up to zoning codes and cities to control how much sprawl they have. A freeway will encourage development outside a major city, but it does not dictate whether there will be single family homes or mixed use projects.
What a disappointing article.
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
IEG Report: Annual Review of Development Effectiveness, Part II
Part II: Achieving Sustainable Development
This is the second part of the IEG: Annual Review of Development Effectiveness for the World Bank. Here are the main points from the report, which is focused on sustainable development in the second half:
- The World Bank ahs a critical role to play in assisting nations in addressing environmental challenges and promoting sustainable practices.
- Sustainable development, poverty reduction, and economic growth are not mutually exclusive.
-The World Bank has evolved over the years with how they handle environmental issues, but need to do more promoting sustainable development for poverty reduction.
- Environmental issues are also quality of life issues
- The process of “mainstreaming” environmental sustainability for development projects and projects in other sectors is not as good as hoped, it is up to The Bank to lead the way and encourage better/smarter practices.
- Most of the funding for sustainable development is going into Africa.
- Bank awareness of biodiversity and other environmental issues is pretty good, and there’s been a large increase in funding for these types of projects in the last decade.
- Global and international environmental policies and sustainable development practices need to be developed.
I see the validity in encouraging sustainable development. On a note outside the report, I do want to point out that building roads isn’t necessarily an unsustainable practice. There has been a large push to mass transit in the west as an effective way of moving people, but in many emerging economies pollution issues have more to do with industry and factories than building roads. Steel for rail has to come from some rendering process, and even solar panels require a lot of chemicals. No one really considers what to do with unused sustainable energy products since that hasn’t become an issue yet, but what’s going to happen when the solar panels in the farms need to be replaced? Can they be reused or are we creating waste that is more difficult to deal with? Roads require maintenance, but so does all types of infrastructure. Traffic impacts and pollution from cars is another regulatory mechanism completely.
This is the second part of the IEG: Annual Review of Development Effectiveness for the World Bank. Here are the main points from the report, which is focused on sustainable development in the second half:
- The World Bank ahs a critical role to play in assisting nations in addressing environmental challenges and promoting sustainable practices.
- Sustainable development, poverty reduction, and economic growth are not mutually exclusive.
-The World Bank has evolved over the years with how they handle environmental issues, but need to do more promoting sustainable development for poverty reduction.
- Environmental issues are also quality of life issues
- The process of “mainstreaming” environmental sustainability for development projects and projects in other sectors is not as good as hoped, it is up to The Bank to lead the way and encourage better/smarter practices.
- Most of the funding for sustainable development is going into Africa.
- Bank awareness of biodiversity and other environmental issues is pretty good, and there’s been a large increase in funding for these types of projects in the last decade.
- Global and international environmental policies and sustainable development practices need to be developed.
I see the validity in encouraging sustainable development. On a note outside the report, I do want to point out that building roads isn’t necessarily an unsustainable practice. There has been a large push to mass transit in the west as an effective way of moving people, but in many emerging economies pollution issues have more to do with industry and factories than building roads. Steel for rail has to come from some rendering process, and even solar panels require a lot of chemicals. No one really considers what to do with unused sustainable energy products since that hasn’t become an issue yet, but what’s going to happen when the solar panels in the farms need to be replaced? Can they be reused or are we creating waste that is more difficult to deal with? Roads require maintenance, but so does all types of infrastructure. Traffic impacts and pollution from cars is another regulatory mechanism completely.
Friday, October 23, 2009
News: Corruption in Russia, not really news
With the World Bank reform talks centering around the issues of corruption, this piece in the LA times about bribing traffic cops is relevant. If passengers are having these issues, it can only be imagined the problems commercial truckers and other road-based commercial transactions are having.
Article is by by Megan K. Stack and was originally published in August of this year.
"Before we start to look for trash in the eye of the traffic policeman, we should look into our own eyes," he says. "When I am asked, 'When will the corruption stop?' I always say that it will only stop when we stop paying bribes."
And, of course, he's right. But here's what I say, nevertheless: Pay the bribe! Because once I fumbled naively onto the path of the righteous and, my friends, it is a trail of sorrows.
If you pay the bribe, it may cost you $40, $60, maybe $100, plus 15 minutes and a few curses muttered under the breath.
If you don't pay the bribe, you have to go to traffic court. And it takes months to get a court date, and meanwhile you don't have a license, even if it's your American license.
And if you need to, for example, get that license back because you are leaving for a vacation in the United States and you want to drive while you're there, then you may (let's pretend this is hypothetical) have to hunt down the man in the bowels of the traffic bureaucracy who is powerful enough to get that license back. And that bribe will be plenty steep; lots more than you'd have paid on the side of the road. Hypothetically.
You travel to some sad sagging building where stray dogs howl at the doors and pay what you have to pay. At least that's over, you think."
Full Article is here
Article is by by Megan K. Stack and was originally published in August of this year.
"Before we start to look for trash in the eye of the traffic policeman, we should look into our own eyes," he says. "When I am asked, 'When will the corruption stop?' I always say that it will only stop when we stop paying bribes."
And, of course, he's right. But here's what I say, nevertheless: Pay the bribe! Because once I fumbled naively onto the path of the righteous and, my friends, it is a trail of sorrows.
If you pay the bribe, it may cost you $40, $60, maybe $100, plus 15 minutes and a few curses muttered under the breath.
If you don't pay the bribe, you have to go to traffic court. And it takes months to get a court date, and meanwhile you don't have a license, even if it's your American license.
And if you need to, for example, get that license back because you are leaving for a vacation in the United States and you want to drive while you're there, then you may (let's pretend this is hypothetical) have to hunt down the man in the bowels of the traffic bureaucracy who is powerful enough to get that license back. And that bribe will be plenty steep; lots more than you'd have paid on the side of the road. Hypothetically.
You travel to some sad sagging building where stray dogs howl at the doors and pay what you have to pay. At least that's over, you think."
Full Article is here
Projects: Armenia Road Rehabilitation
Looking back on the World Bank transportation infrastructure improvements for 2009, the most recently approved project is actually additional funding for the Armenia: Lifeline Roads Improvement Project which is funded out of the IRBD. $36.6 million USD with a standard 25 year loan (with a 10 year grace period) to rehab 140 km of roads in rural Armenia. Here's the reason for the additional funds (available in the project description):
This project paper concerns to provide an additional loan to the Republic of Armenia for the Lifeline Roads Improvement Project (LRIP). The additional loan will finance the scaling up of the project's activities through rehabilitating an additional 140 kilometers of the lifeline road network. This additional loan will also help mitigate the impact of the financial crisis by creating temporary jobs in road construction. This additional financing (AF) will also finance the design of project roads, supervision of works, capacity development in pavement design and road safety, project operating costs, and financial and technical audits. The project development objective (PDO) will remain the same as in the original project. The results framework and the monitoring indicators have been revised to reflect the increased scope of the project. The implementation arrangements remain the same as in the original project. There will be no co-financing from other donors. The closing date is being extended by one year, from December 31, 2010 to December 31, 2011.
The additional funds were approved of August of this year, but no new project proposals for transportation have happened in the second half of the year. Looks like the World Bank is setting the stage with government reform programs/money in Georgia and Armenia and adding additional funding to infrastructure projects in Azerbaijan. Hopefully a more exciting project will come out of the World Bank next year, otherwise it looks like private developers are having all the fun.
This project paper concerns to provide an additional loan to the Republic of Armenia for the Lifeline Roads Improvement Project (LRIP). The additional loan will finance the scaling up of the project's activities through rehabilitating an additional 140 kilometers of the lifeline road network. This additional loan will also help mitigate the impact of the financial crisis by creating temporary jobs in road construction. This additional financing (AF) will also finance the design of project roads, supervision of works, capacity development in pavement design and road safety, project operating costs, and financial and technical audits. The project development objective (PDO) will remain the same as in the original project. The results framework and the monitoring indicators have been revised to reflect the increased scope of the project. The implementation arrangements remain the same as in the original project. There will be no co-financing from other donors. The closing date is being extended by one year, from December 31, 2010 to December 31, 2011.
The additional funds were approved of August of this year, but no new project proposals for transportation have happened in the second half of the year. Looks like the World Bank is setting the stage with government reform programs/money in Georgia and Armenia and adding additional funding to infrastructure projects in Azerbaijan. Hopefully a more exciting project will come out of the World Bank next year, otherwise it looks like private developers are having all the fun.
Labels:
additional financing,
armenia,
azerbaijan,
georgia,
roads,
World Bank
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
How Effective is Transportation Infrastructure? A Literature Review
Although few studies have been done on the impact of infrastructure development in transition economics and the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), many studies have been conducted to examine the cost-benefit relationships of building new roads, as well as the development of these networks within other transition economies. Studies have generally shown that there is a positive relationship between transit infrastructure and economic growth, as well as that infrastructure capital “increased industry and national productivity in the United States” (Aghion and Schankerman 1999: 82). The first of the studies being reviewed for the purposes of this paper is Philippe Aghion and Mark Schankerman’s article “Competition, entry and the social returns to infrastructure in transition economies”. The main argument of their study is that “the potential for developing competitive markets in transition economics has been inhibited by the inadequacy of both the institutional and physical infrastructure” (Aghion and Schankerman 1999). The authors continue to suggest that in order to assist success in transition economies that governments and multi-lateral aid agencies need to find a way to quantifiable measure the social returns from infrastructure projects and how these factors influence economic performance.
Although Aghion and Schankerman’s study also provides insight to the lack of development of government and telecommunications infrastructure in transition economies, their study centers on if and how transportation infrastructure helps promote market competition. Their paper finds that “indirect effects of infrastructure investment depend on features of the economic environment, including the number of firms in the market (initial density), the degree of cost asymmetry, the proportion of high cost firms, and the initial level of competition (or transaction costs)” (Aghion and Schankerman 1999: 98). Most of the demand for infrastructure, according to the authors, depends on the political economy, which has serious implications for the transition economies and governments of the CIS. If the political economy is one of the most important factors in the success of development from the building of infrastructure, than the historical evidence would seem to suggest that the more liberal the nation, the more successful transport infrastructure will be in facilitating economic and social growth.
Aghion and Schankerman’s model includes measures for government and telecommunications infrastructure as well as transportation. Overall their study shows that there is a relationship between developing infrastructure and economic growth and political liberalization. What is unclear is the distribution of winners and losers that the authors reference in terms of low-cost and high-cost firms. The authors also suggest that the research they created should be followed with a more in-depth analysis of political economy and how that essentially impacts the effectiveness of infrastructure in economic development.
Feinberg and Meurs’s paper “Market Report, Infrastructure and Exchange Rate Passthrough in Central and Eastern Europe” provides an alternative to Aghion and Schankerman’s argument that “physical infrastructure is crucial for competitive market development” (Feinger and Meurs 2005: 23). Feinber and Meurs found the infrastructure in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) inferior to the needs of the nations. They also point out that the World Bank and other international agencies have made infrastructure development a priority for project lending, but that the economic failures of the states that received many of these loans left the infrastructure in disrepair or insufficient for growth. (Feinberg and Meurs 2005)
In this study, Feinberg and Meurs analyze “13 broad industry sectors for the years 1991-200 for Bulgaria, Hungary, Poland, Romania, and Slovenia with data…and (6) an index (constructed by the authors) of physical infrastructure in the five countries” (Feingber and Meurs 2005: 24). The results of the paper finds the impacts of physical infrastructure unclear but that “market reforms (improving the legal/institutional infrastructure) in Central and Eastern Europe have had the desired effect of increasing the integration of these countries’ economies into the global economic system, with gains in the competitiveness of domestic markets” (Feinberg and Meurs 2005: 29). Although the relationship between economic growth and the development of physical infrastructure was unclear, the data does suggest that the improvement of physical infrastructure may increase economic growth and capital movement. The authors of the study expected a stronger impact from infrastructure on economic development than what was shown in their results. Although the nation data used in the Feinberg and Meurs study does not include any member of the CIS, the shared history and economic performance of Central and Eastern Europe and the CIS is reasonable. Both studies discussed thus far have found some relationship between infrastructure and economic development. What is interesting is that both authors also account for other types of infrastructure, specifically in terms of government and social programs.
The final component to the literature review is a book by Rietveld and Bruinsma, Is Transport Infrastructure Effective?. The authors take a more economic and urban planning approach to the question, whereas the previous two articles were predominantly social science and economics oriented. Rietveld and Bruinsma discuss infrastructure as it relates to public funding and the impact of it on the delivery of social and economic goods. The financing of infrastructure, according to the authors tends to alternate between public and private financing, depending on the policies in vogue at the time. Overall, however, there has been a decline of funding from the public sector in the last twenty years, the authors cite many causes that may have influenced government spending, specifically the “changing opions about the role of the state in the economy and the society as a whole” in the 1980s (Rietvel and Bruinsma 1998). The authors also suggest the approach taken by Grubler and Nakiconovic in 1991, who found that there was a life-cycle to the funding of infrastructure by the public sector, in which the overlap became increasing smaller between the two. The cycles would include the canal cycle in the beginning of the 19th century, the railway cycle in the first half of the 19th century, the 20th century cycle of road and the current or to be occurring cycle of aviation and telecommunications. (Rietveld and Bruinsma) Although public funding for infrastructure types has seemed to pull away, a simple explanation seems to be that the initial costs and energy required to initially plan, develop, and build the infrastructure are highest and the residual maintenance of these projects makes the state seem less involved in infrastructure as a whole. In some cases, such as in Russia after the dissolution of the Soviet Union, the privatization of rail has also shifted the need for public capital for maintenance into private companies who run freight and passenger rail.
Rietveld and Bruinsma also discuss the issue of accessibility, specifically the ease of use, and the effectiveness of infrastructure. The authors do a fair job compiling other studies that have operationalized these concepts and proceed into a discussion of calculating transport costs. They argue, much like the previous two articles, “transport infrastructure investment lead to changes in generalized transport costs via shorter distances or higher speeds, which give rise to reductions in fuel, capital and labour costs” (Rietveld and Bruinsma 1998: 47). This decrease in transportation costs would, in theory, increase productivity, which will in turn lead to growth of gross domestic product (GDP). Development of infrastructure, specifically accessible and well-planned infrastructure can also positively impact property value, which is also a facilitator of investment and growth in developing and developed nations. For Rietveld and Bruinsma the “inequalities in accessibility are least pronounced in the road network…[however] in the rail network inequalities are clearly higher” (Reitveld and Bruinsma 1998: 139). The better accessibility for road networks are partially due to the actual cost of roads versus rail and also due to the ease of expanding and adding onto existing road networks, whereas expansion and changes in rail and create more problems and cost more. Also roads are more likely to be used for both economic and personal travel, whereas the differences between passenger and industrial rail are more challenging due to the different gauges in rail lines, locomotives, and the planning process differences between industrial and passenger rail.
While plans for roads that serve industrial and residential areas might differ in the amount of capacity and how the network as a whole will react to the new road or linkage, traffic planning models are widely used internationally by Western governments to determine how many lanes are necessary and where connections should be made based on user demand. Rail is harder to determine demand since passenger rail and industrial rail require specialized trains that are able to adapt to the different types of lines, and set schedules are not always able to meet demand, and sometimes can actually run at a higher cost since a train without product or passengers following the schedule might be necessary in order to make the next connection. The remainder of the book delves into comparisons of European accessibility studies, corridor development, and some case studies. With the varying opinions on how to determine and measure accessibility, the author’s comparison is useful and shows that for a most part population, type of transit infrastructure, and usage rates are standard in determining this factor. As a whole, the authors are advocating for the building of road networks, and they show a compelling link between positive influx of GDP due to the development of infrastructure.
Although Aghion and Schankerman’s study also provides insight to the lack of development of government and telecommunications infrastructure in transition economies, their study centers on if and how transportation infrastructure helps promote market competition. Their paper finds that “indirect effects of infrastructure investment depend on features of the economic environment, including the number of firms in the market (initial density), the degree of cost asymmetry, the proportion of high cost firms, and the initial level of competition (or transaction costs)” (Aghion and Schankerman 1999: 98). Most of the demand for infrastructure, according to the authors, depends on the political economy, which has serious implications for the transition economies and governments of the CIS. If the political economy is one of the most important factors in the success of development from the building of infrastructure, than the historical evidence would seem to suggest that the more liberal the nation, the more successful transport infrastructure will be in facilitating economic and social growth.
Aghion and Schankerman’s model includes measures for government and telecommunications infrastructure as well as transportation. Overall their study shows that there is a relationship between developing infrastructure and economic growth and political liberalization. What is unclear is the distribution of winners and losers that the authors reference in terms of low-cost and high-cost firms. The authors also suggest that the research they created should be followed with a more in-depth analysis of political economy and how that essentially impacts the effectiveness of infrastructure in economic development.
Feinberg and Meurs’s paper “Market Report, Infrastructure and Exchange Rate Passthrough in Central and Eastern Europe” provides an alternative to Aghion and Schankerman’s argument that “physical infrastructure is crucial for competitive market development” (Feinger and Meurs 2005: 23). Feinber and Meurs found the infrastructure in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) inferior to the needs of the nations. They also point out that the World Bank and other international agencies have made infrastructure development a priority for project lending, but that the economic failures of the states that received many of these loans left the infrastructure in disrepair or insufficient for growth. (Feinberg and Meurs 2005)
In this study, Feinberg and Meurs analyze “13 broad industry sectors for the years 1991-200 for Bulgaria, Hungary, Poland, Romania, and Slovenia with data…and (6) an index (constructed by the authors) of physical infrastructure in the five countries” (Feingber and Meurs 2005: 24). The results of the paper finds the impacts of physical infrastructure unclear but that “market reforms (improving the legal/institutional infrastructure) in Central and Eastern Europe have had the desired effect of increasing the integration of these countries’ economies into the global economic system, with gains in the competitiveness of domestic markets” (Feinberg and Meurs 2005: 29). Although the relationship between economic growth and the development of physical infrastructure was unclear, the data does suggest that the improvement of physical infrastructure may increase economic growth and capital movement. The authors of the study expected a stronger impact from infrastructure on economic development than what was shown in their results. Although the nation data used in the Feinberg and Meurs study does not include any member of the CIS, the shared history and economic performance of Central and Eastern Europe and the CIS is reasonable. Both studies discussed thus far have found some relationship between infrastructure and economic development. What is interesting is that both authors also account for other types of infrastructure, specifically in terms of government and social programs.
The final component to the literature review is a book by Rietveld and Bruinsma, Is Transport Infrastructure Effective?. The authors take a more economic and urban planning approach to the question, whereas the previous two articles were predominantly social science and economics oriented. Rietveld and Bruinsma discuss infrastructure as it relates to public funding and the impact of it on the delivery of social and economic goods. The financing of infrastructure, according to the authors tends to alternate between public and private financing, depending on the policies in vogue at the time. Overall, however, there has been a decline of funding from the public sector in the last twenty years, the authors cite many causes that may have influenced government spending, specifically the “changing opions about the role of the state in the economy and the society as a whole” in the 1980s (Rietvel and Bruinsma 1998). The authors also suggest the approach taken by Grubler and Nakiconovic in 1991, who found that there was a life-cycle to the funding of infrastructure by the public sector, in which the overlap became increasing smaller between the two. The cycles would include the canal cycle in the beginning of the 19th century, the railway cycle in the first half of the 19th century, the 20th century cycle of road and the current or to be occurring cycle of aviation and telecommunications. (Rietveld and Bruinsma) Although public funding for infrastructure types has seemed to pull away, a simple explanation seems to be that the initial costs and energy required to initially plan, develop, and build the infrastructure are highest and the residual maintenance of these projects makes the state seem less involved in infrastructure as a whole. In some cases, such as in Russia after the dissolution of the Soviet Union, the privatization of rail has also shifted the need for public capital for maintenance into private companies who run freight and passenger rail.
Rietveld and Bruinsma also discuss the issue of accessibility, specifically the ease of use, and the effectiveness of infrastructure. The authors do a fair job compiling other studies that have operationalized these concepts and proceed into a discussion of calculating transport costs. They argue, much like the previous two articles, “transport infrastructure investment lead to changes in generalized transport costs via shorter distances or higher speeds, which give rise to reductions in fuel, capital and labour costs” (Rietveld and Bruinsma 1998: 47). This decrease in transportation costs would, in theory, increase productivity, which will in turn lead to growth of gross domestic product (GDP). Development of infrastructure, specifically accessible and well-planned infrastructure can also positively impact property value, which is also a facilitator of investment and growth in developing and developed nations. For Rietveld and Bruinsma the “inequalities in accessibility are least pronounced in the road network…[however] in the rail network inequalities are clearly higher” (Reitveld and Bruinsma 1998: 139). The better accessibility for road networks are partially due to the actual cost of roads versus rail and also due to the ease of expanding and adding onto existing road networks, whereas expansion and changes in rail and create more problems and cost more. Also roads are more likely to be used for both economic and personal travel, whereas the differences between passenger and industrial rail are more challenging due to the different gauges in rail lines, locomotives, and the planning process differences between industrial and passenger rail.
While plans for roads that serve industrial and residential areas might differ in the amount of capacity and how the network as a whole will react to the new road or linkage, traffic planning models are widely used internationally by Western governments to determine how many lanes are necessary and where connections should be made based on user demand. Rail is harder to determine demand since passenger rail and industrial rail require specialized trains that are able to adapt to the different types of lines, and set schedules are not always able to meet demand, and sometimes can actually run at a higher cost since a train without product or passengers following the schedule might be necessary in order to make the next connection. The remainder of the book delves into comparisons of European accessibility studies, corridor development, and some case studies. With the varying opinions on how to determine and measure accessibility, the author’s comparison is useful and shows that for a most part population, type of transit infrastructure, and usage rates are standard in determining this factor. As a whole, the authors are advocating for the building of road networks, and they show a compelling link between positive influx of GDP due to the development of infrastructure.

